General Hospital fans are in a frenzy after recent episodes hinted that Britt may have orchestrated Nathan‘s supposed death. Viewers are now questioning whether his demise was real or just another twist in the soap’s long-running drama.
Social media is buzzing with theories, with fans dissecting every scene for clues. Some believe Britt’s actions point to a darker side, while others think Nathan’s return is fake and an imposter.
As tensions rise in Port Charles, check out all the latest audience theories made so far.
General Hospital fans believe the Nathan who returned ‘is a nice guy’
General Hospital enthusiasts have long maintained hope that Nathan’s return is real and signifies a redemptive storyline. Numerous viewers are eager for Nathan to be the kind, dependable character they know — someone who exemplifies compassion, loyalty, and integrity (via Soap Hub).
Despite the intrigue and enigma surrounding his comeback, fans believe in the “nice guy” persona. Their trust in his fundamental goodness provides them with something to hold onto amidst the chaos of deceit and mistrust in Port Charles.
The theory of the “nice Nathan” hypothesis cites his interactions with other characters as proof. They hold that even if there are hidden truths, his essence appears too sincere to overlook.
But on the flip side, many others strongly disagree. In online discussions, fans have pointed out moments where Britt casts doubts on Nathan, declines enthusiastic hugs, or seems to believe something is off.
Britt, however, was not at all pleased to see her brother. Yet, General Hospital fans were quick to observe Britt’s treatment of Nathan and took to social media to voice their opinions. One X (formerly Twitter) user remarked, “Why is Britt looking at Nathan like this? What is going on? Is that really him?”
A Facebook user commented on this theory and shared their perspective on Nathan still being the good guy, suggesting that Britt might be the one who faked his death by stating, “Ok so hear me out!! What if he actually is a nice guy he’s not coming back as anybody other than himself, and Brit is the one that faked his death and is worried about getting caught ?!?!?! I mean this scene really seemed genuine with James!! I really don’t want Nathan to be a bad guy.”
