“I could well be Shabana Patil and she Smita Azmi!” Celebrating 69 Years Of Smita Patil

Who discovered Smita Patil for cinema? We  all think it is  Shyam Benegal. But veteran  actor-director Manoj Kumar says he spotted Smita  first and offered  her his wife’s role in  Shor after Sharmila Tagore suddenly opted out. Smita  excused herself arguing that she  wasn’t ready for a  film career yet. It was  Shyam  Benegal who launched Smita. Benegal  cast Smita in some of her most memorable roles in Manthan and Bhumika. But he clearly gave his other favourite Shabana Azmi the much bigger portion of roles.A fact that Smita deeply resented. The rivalry between the actresses persisted right till her death.

After Smita’s sudden and shocking death, Shabana Azmi had spoken on the rivalry  and  deep  bonding . “I have had the privilege of working with Smita in Nishant, Arth, Mandi and Oonch Neech Beech in roles far removed from each other. I felt both challenged and inspired by her as a co actor.We had so much in common; we came from similar backgrounds, were launched by the same director, had similiar aesthetics and worked in the same kind of cinema. Today in public memory Smita and I are so closely bonded together that I feel I could well be Shabana Patil and she Smita Azmi! She had a short career span and yet 29 years after she passed away Parallel cinema in India will never be mentioned without Smita Patil’s name emblazoned in golden letters.”

About their  troubled relationship Shabana had said, “Alas! We could never be friends. The rivalry between us , some of it manufactured by the media and some of it real , caused friction. I’ve said this before and I acknowledge it again that I have been guilty of making uncharitable remarks about her and I regret it. There were efforts at reconciliation and we were able to maintain civility but it never turned into friendship.But at no point did that spill over to our families. Smita was a star by the time she did Sagar Sarhadi’s Bazaar and obviously she was given the best room in the hotel. My mother Shaukat Kaifi was doing a small but significant role in the film. When she joined the unit in Hyderabad two weeks later Smita insisted on giving up her room for my mother and quietly shifted into a smaller room. It was only later that mummy realised what Smita had done and protested but Smita would have none of it.Such was the graciousness that came naturally to her because she was the daughter of Vidyatai and Shivajirao Patil who had instilled such impeccable values in her.Her family Ma , Pappa, Anita , Manya have embraced me as one of their own.Human relationships are complex and I am deeply grateful for the trust they have placed in me.It’s a very personal thing I’m sharing. There was a time in young Prateik’s life when he was troubled, directionless and didn’t know what to do.Both Ma and Anita asked me to take over his charge. Need I say more?Smita was a microcosm of India -traditional and modern, strong and fragile, confident and vulnerable.I would marvel at the panache with which she drove a jeep from Bombay to Delhi with only a girlfriend for company, fixing flat tires and camping in remote places. She rode a motorbike like a professional and played volleyball like a champion. She was ‘one of the boys’ on the sets of Mandi. But she was also very feminine and deeply traditional , at times easily intimidated. I think its these contradictions that were both her strength and her weakness. But it was also that that made her an artist who will always be spoken of when the finest actors of Indian cinema are counted.”

Recalling her first meeting with Smita, Shabana had said, “I first set eyes on her in an FTII diploma film directed by Arun Khopkar. I think it was called Teevra Madhyam. There was a long shot in which she was playing the tanpura.I was struck by her raw beauty and the stillness she exuded. She was born for the camera. It lingered over her face and she held it captive without the slightest effort.”

 A few years later Shabana  met Smita Patil on the sets of Shyam Benegal’s Nishant. “It was a difficult part for one as young as her. In the film her husband played by Naseerudin Shah gets enamoured by my character Sushila , kidnaps her and brings her home. Smita smoulders in jealousy anger hurt and rage but doesnt say anything. Her face expresses it all. It is clearly an antagonistic relationship between the two women.It is to Shyam Benegal’s credit and understanding of the complexities of feudal societies ,ably aided by Vijay Tendulkars script that two small but significant scenes stand out. Smita comes into my room to offer me food because I haven’t eaten for days. On the surface matter of fact, slightly resentful too, Smita played that scene with such a layer of empathy that the plight of the two women bonded together through a patriarchal feudal structure , brought tears to my eyes without even trying.That is the crux of what film acting is about, a collaborative effort in which how good your work is depends on the work of your co actors.”